Cole Crops


Herbs & Flowers


Cold Frames
Eating Garden
Green Manure
Potting Soil
Raised Beds

Seed Sources

Q & A & Notes




Organic Gardening with Sue Robishaw

from Cucumber in the Garden
to Pickle in the Pantry

cucumber plants

Four decades of Growing Good Food in Michigan's Upper Peninsula
~ ~ ~
Down to Earth Information, Experiences, Thoughts

Pickles may not be a required food group but they are close to the top of my food preservation list. They are particularly appreciated when the salad ingredients are sparse while the garden rests during its long hibernation. Pickles are why I grow and love cucumbers.

Bookmark and Share


"Growing Berries
for Food and Fun"


"Garden Song"
video link

Garden Song video thumbnail link

Contact Us



August 7, 2019 -- First Pickles of the Season

Someone ate my first planting of cucumber seeds this spring (and the squash, too!) so I replanted later than I normally plant. Being concerned that the crop would be limited because of that I planted extras. Turns out that wasn't at all necessary and I now have a crowded, thriving, green jungle of cucumber plants in my plot, happily putting out cucs right and left and right on schedule. They know when it's time to produce. Plants probably get quite a chuckle at human's fussing and calendar watching.

They did catch me a bit by surprise, since I thought they'd be later, but when I noticed some full sized cucumbers I was quite happy to grab a basket and pick enough for the first batch of fermented pickles. I do both fermented and vinegar pickles; not so many of the first and more of the second since they last longer. The ferments are for "fresh" eating while the vinegared are mostly cut up in salads and dishes.

Since ferments are alive and ever changing their shelf life is limited. How long they are good depends a lot on the temperature and the season and weather. The first batch of the season is barely given time to get going before being eaten since it's been a good long while since we've had any. In a week or two we'll start sampling this first batch. They won't last long. But they are very easy to make so more will be on their way soon. I spread out my pickling - a small batch of ferments now, then several batches of vinegar, which aren't hard to make but they take a bit more time so it depends on my schedule and how the cucs are ripening. This year I think I'll be giving cucumbers away!

ferment picklesBut not until the pickle shelf is full. If you've never had fresh fermented pickles you might want to give them a try. We like them. I'd made them off and on through the years, using directions from here and there, coming up with my own recipe. Usually they turned out good, though it's not a sure thing. But a few years ago I bought a book that got me enthused once again about ferments - "Fermented Vegetables" by Kirsten and Christopher Shockey. Now most of their well written and wonderfully photographed book is a bit lost on me, being quite fond of simplicity in my own kitchen/preserving life and not much inclined to add to it. But I enjoyed reading the book anyway and was really amazed at the array of ferments. They do a great job of explaining the ins and outs and particulars of fermenting - well worth it even if you don't want to ferment everything in sight. I did try a few new things and came up with an adaptation of their onion and sweet pepper relish that I really liked. I'll do that one again when my peppers are ripe. It's a fun book.

Ferments are pretty basic and simple. My recipe is basic and simple. The tools required are simple, too. I made many a pickle, and sauerkraut, in a crock with a plate and a rock or jar of water for a weight. It works, and I still do that sometimes. But skimming off the scum is a bit fussy. I found that for pickles doing them directly in a jar works better - no or little skum to skim. But last year I discovered something even easier - Pickle Pipes made by MasonTops, along with their PicklePebbles glass weights. I started with a set of four, and it wasn't long before I ordered another set. I made do with those 8 last year, using a crock until a PicklePipe and Pebble was free then transferring to a jar. I'm not much for gizmos, especially in my kitchen, but I have to say these things are not only cute they simply make ferments easy, more reliable and trouble free.  

So this is how I (usually) do it now:

Scrub and slice medium sized pickling cucumbers (large ones tend to get mushy). Pack firmly into into a wide mouth quart jar along with these optional options:
2 cloves garlic
fresh green dill flowers/seeds (whatever stage is available) 
grape leaf or horseradish root piece
1 tsp mixed pickling spice

Leave about 2" headroom if using Pipe & Pebble (less if not). Weight with a PicklePebble.
Cover with brine made of 1 1/2 TB plain salt to quart of water 
Put on a PicklePipe with metal ring

Leave for 3-5 days in kitchen (or somewhere around 70 deg) to begin ferment, then move to cooler space, for me this is the root cellar at about 60 deg this time of year. Start testing in about a week or two. Start eating when you like the flavor. Move to a pint jar when half eaten. The ferment brine is good, too, and good for you. It adds a real nice flavor to bread or baked goods, or general cooking that needs liquid.

The last fermented pickles made end of season in September have kept fairly well until March but they do tend to get soft by then, and that's the end of the fermented pickles until the next season. These later pickles get cooler storage temps as the root cellar starts cooling down in October and is down to 40 degrees in November.

But that's a long ways off. Meantime, we look forward to the first fresh fermented pickles in a week or two.

Cucumbers are good eaten fresh, too, of course, but mine prefer to be pickled.
So the cucumber I grow is the pickling sort. I’ve trialed many open-pollinated varieties and so far Northern Pickling is the choice for my garden. Cucumbers love warmth and space but there are varieties that can suit a wide range of environments, from bush sorts for the small plot or those that can be trained up a trellis, ones that are more adaptable to the hot and dry or varieties that handle the cooler climes with finesse. The best way to choose the variety (or varieties) for your garden is to experiment with many different ones, then grow what does best for you.

If your garden is healthy and the soil reasonably rich in humus, you will probably grow great healthy cucumbers. But even when I was still building up my depleted sandy-loam soil I was able to get a small but usable cucumber crop. They make do with what they have, just as people do, but do best in an environment that suits them (as do people!). Since we have a fairly short growing season here in the upper Midwest my goal is to get the plants growing strong as early as possible to get a good crop before the frosts and freezes arrive in the fall. Cucumbers are not fond of frost.

early spring cold framePLANTING - Warmer climate gardeners plant their seed directly in the garden, grow and harvest cucumbers as they mature and don’t worry much about a freeze prematurely ending their harvest. But those of us with shorter seasons need to take a bit more care if we want enough fruit for pickling. You can start your cucumbers inside in small pots, transplanting them out later when the soil warms and weather settles, and I have done that successfully. But my small greenhouse space is at a premium in the spring and the less fussing I have to do with any crop the happier I am. And a happier gardener makes for happier plants! So I use cold frames.
When the snow is gone from the garden, the dandelions are showing their cheery blossoms, the apple tree’s buds are swelling and the daffodils are in full bloom, it feels great to be out in the garden soaking up the sun, moving mulch and digging in the dirt. Many seeds have already found their way into their respective plots -- early greens, peas, carrot. Now it is time to set out portable cold frames for the squash and cucumbers -- usually about mid-May here. The cold frames suit me and the cucumbers. I can put them where I want them with little fuss, and the plants can settle in without worrying about having to move later.

As I have permanent, mulched, four foot wide beds, my preparation means moving mulch instead of digging or tilling the soil. I rake the mulch off a bed where the cucumbers will reside so the soil can warm. The cold frame boxes are set out at a spacing of about three frames in 24 feet. A shovel of compost is dug into the top inches of soil within the frame and several seeds are planted in each quarter of the box. I cover them gently with dirt and, with a loving pat, leave them to do what they most want to do -- grow. When the seedlings are up and growing but still small, they are thinned to one plant per corner. This works out to about one plant per eight square feet which is a good spacing for the Northern Pickling variety.

Since this is still about a month before our weather warms and frosts abate, the cold frame windows are closed at night and during cloudy cool days, then propped open when the sun shines. If temps really drop, the frame is easily covered with an old blanket or rug. This gives the crop a wonderful head start on the season without unduly pushing their comfort level. The most important job for the gardener during this time is to be sure to prop open the windows when it is sunny. Better to have a bit of cool than to cook the little plants. If I’m going to be gone overnight and I’m not sure of the weather, I’ll leave the cold frame closed and covered with a blanket. The plants do fine with a few days of extended dark.

GROWING - Round about the second half of June the weather is usually settling into summer mode. The garden is starting to look like a garden and the cucumbers and other plants are happily growing. Except for an occasionally cold summer, the cold frames are taken off and stored away and the cucumbers are ready to spread out. It’s time to mulch. Not surprising, it’s also time to cut hay. Nature does work things out pretty neatly.
Since we have fields, we cut our own hay for mulch. It’s wonderful to work with loose hay, and one can be sure to cut at the right time (before things go to seed). The old mulch may be raked back on the bed now, supplemented with new hay. Or it may stay in the paths to keep weeds down there and the bed covered with fresh stuff, nestling up around the growing cucumber plants. Either way, the entire garden is blanketed with mulch by July and the gardener happily tends to other summer fun; the mulch pretty much taking the place of weeding and watering.

The cucumber plants grow and spread and, other than admiring them, my only chore during this time is to direct enthusiastic vines out of the path and back onto the bed.

HARVEST - Towards the end of July I can usually start eating cucumbers on my salad. Since I only grow pickling cucumbers, I simply peel them for eating raw. But fresh cucumber aficionados will, of course, have their favorite eating varieties and be raiding the patch when the first ones become of size, and from then on. But in the pickle patch we’re waiting for that time when there are enough little critters for a nice batch of pickles. This is why I grow cucumbers so “salad ingredient” is just a sideline. From then on it’s a game of watching and picking them before they get too large, yet having enough for a decent sized batch of pickles. Those that become oversized are tossed into the compost pile. Thus does August progress; and on a rare mild fall, on into September.

mature cucumbersSAVING SEED - If you grow open pollinated cucumbers and a good number of plants (you want a reasonable gene pool, not just saving from one or two plants), saving your own seed is as easy as just letting some of the cucumbers of each plant mature. Cucumbers cross pollinate, so I grow only one variety if I'm saving seed. If you store your seed well (cool, dry, dark) it will be viable for many years so you don't have to save seed every year. If the plants and fruit are having a good year - disease free, generous production of fruit, good weather for maturing - I simply choose to leave a cucumber here and there to mature, usually the ones that escaped my notice and have already grown beyond the nice pickling stage. If it's a great year, I simply stop harvesting when I'm tired of making pickles and let the rest of the crop mature.

Maturing cucumbers will turn yellow then dark orange or yellow and their skin/shell becomes less tender as they age, well past . Light frosts don't bother them even if the leaves are damaged and I leave them in the garden until hard freezes are predicted. I then bring them inside to set and further mature their seeds for at least several weeks (which isn't hard since I'm plenty busy doing other things this time of year). At some point before they get too soft and mushy I cut them open and scoop the seeds out into a bowl. There's usually enough juice to let them ferment (which takes care of that gelatinous covering on the seed and might take care of some diseases, too). If not, add a little water. Stir several times a day and let them ferment for several days. Then clean the seed. I do this by adding water, letting the seeds settle to the bottom, pouring off the debris. Keep doing this until the seed is clean, then strain and dump on a towel to remove as much water as possible. Spread out on a plate or cookie sheet and let air dry until they snap when bent. Old envelopes work well for seed packets (note the year and where you originally got the seed, as well as the proper name). Store in a cool, dry, dark place and you'll have more then enough seed for you and your friends for many years.

pickles in roote cellarPICKLES - There is hardly a need for me to give a pickle recipe. They are so prevalent that one could spend all ones days trialing pickle recipes and never run out, even should you live several lifetimes! Pickles have to be tops in the preserving category for fun, variety, sharing and friendly community. Cucumbers aren’t the only vegetable used for pickles, of course, but they are the top contender. When I’ve been short on cucumbers I’ve successfully used small zucchini and other squashes. Peppers and onions are often additions to the pickle pot, or maybe some broccoli.

VINEGAR PICKLES - For all of that, I have to admit that I have, except for an occasional foray elsewhere, for almost thirty years used but one recipe. I cannot call myself a member of the elite pickler contingent with that. But we do love the pickles I make! And if we run out it’s a major disappointment. In spite of being mostly the same for all these years, they have and do change. The recipe was originally from the “Joy of Cooking” many years ago and called “Sweet Sour Spiced Pickles” made with vinegar, sugar, and spice (and cucumbers). I’ve changed ingredients and proportions of sugar to vinegar, used maple syrup or turbinado or sucanet instead white sugar, use cider vinegar instead of white, and used different combinations of pickling and other spices; added onions, peppers, broccoli, and made and eaten hundreds of jars of this, our favorite pickle. My version is fairly strong and I use it mainly chopped up into our daily luncheon “salad” (which is itself ever changing and hardly typical) and into other dishes. This is the way I made one batch last year:

Slice fresh cucumbers into a brine of 1/3 cup pickling salt to 1 quart water, let set overnight or all day (or overnight and all day)
Per pound of cucumbers (or about 3 cups) bring to a simmer/brief boil:
1 3/4 cups cider vinegar* and
3/4 cup sucanet or turbinado (or other brown sugar)

In each pint jar put 1 tsp mixed pickling spice (with cinnamon and cloves), some dill, a few small grape leaves.

Drain brine off cucumbers, cover with hot water, drain. Pack not too tightly into jars. Cover with hot vinegar/sugar solution leaving 1/2” headroom. Lid and process as you normally do (boil-water-bath or steam-pressure-canner can) for 10 minutes. Or don’t process, if you don’t do that to your pickles. I used to, but don’t anymore. I make sure the vinegar solution is boiling hot, fill to about 1/4” headroom, put heated lids on the jars with rings just as if I were going to process them, then let them be. They seal and keep just fine, and it’s a lot less work. If a jar doesn’t seal it is obvious and that jar gets put in the root cellar and eaten early. All other precautions are the same as with any canning.

*My favorite is when we have a bumper apple crop, make more apple cider than we can drink, and I make a large batch of good, strong apple cider vinegar to use for the pickles. It’s a flavor you just can’t get with factory vinegar and I cherish it when I have it.

FERMENTED PICKLES - In the past we didn’t eat many pickles plain out of the jar, until last year I discovered “Fermented Brined Pickles”. Hardly new, of course, it is probably the original pickle. Most people are familiar with sauerkraut, but not so with other brined vegetables. But apparently the time was right for me to re-discover brined pickles. I happened on an old book in the library, read the section on fermented pickles and was intrigued. It sounded so easy, and I’m all for less fuss-more fun; so I searched some more. I searched through the large pickle section of the library and gleaned some information and recipes, and I searched online and found more. It’s not as common as canned or vinegar pickles, but there is a lot of good info out there (and passionate proponents) and I soon had a pretty good understanding of the process. Which is good when you are trying something new. What really interested me was the possibility of fermenting in the jar, not in a crock.

Well, we had a good crop of pickles and I had collected a good number of fermented pickle recipes. I was conservative and only tried six variations. Really, they were all pretty much the same, but a little more salt here, little less there, quart jar, gallon jar, small crock; no dill, some dill, lots of dill; grape leaves vs cherry leaves; onions and peppers in one, just cucs in others. It’s amazing how complicated you can make a very simple thing! But it was fun. And we loved the pickles! I made 27 quarts of fermented pickles and we ran out in February. And we are only two people (and two cats but they didn’t share our pickle passion). Granted, I did give many jars away as gifts, pickles seem made for that. But we had discovered a great new-old food. How wonderful that it was also easy and good.

If you aren’t already a pickle fermenter, I’d suggest you research and read and get familiar with the process (which is easy) and methods (not many). But be prepared, home fermented pickles are not like always-the-same factory pickles. They are alive and change flavor daily from the day they are made until the day they are eaten, which is part of the fun, and delicious fun it is. Hopefully this year I will have a great cucumber year and have enough pickles to see how they taste past the 6 month mark (which is when we ate the last of last year’s pickles).

All of the different recipes I tried were good, but this simple one is probably my favorite:

Make a brine of 1 1/2 tablespoons pickling salt to 1 quart of water. Slice cucumbers into a quart jar, include some dill and grape leaves. Cover to near the top with brine. Put on the lid and let set (on a towel is a good idea) at room temp for about 5 days or so, when the brine will be cloudy and definitely fermenting (little bubbles rising). Wipe off jars and lids, top with more brine if needed , and store in pantry or cool space which calms down the fermenting.

Start eating whenever you want, and keep eating until they are gone.

The great thing about the fermented pickle is you can easily make small batches as the cucumbers come along. Or large batches even if you’re busy with other things. They don’t take long. You can use whole cucumbers, quartered cucumbers, sliced cucumbers, other vegetables. When a bunch of cucumbers were ready to be picked but I was busy with other things, I quickly picked and washed them, put them whole into a small crock and covered with brine. A small weighted plate (a glass jar of water works well) keeps the cucumbers beneath the brine. Place a cloth cover over the whole and let it set and ferment as with the jarred pickles. Then later at my convenience I sliced them into jars.

You can ferment in the jar or in a crock. But if you ferment in a crock, you have to skim the white scum off regularly which is why I prefer the jar method -- it’s easier and less messy -- the scum doesn’t form. One change I will make this year is to use plastic canning jar tops for these pickles. The brine did a number on my regular metal rings and I’ve had to toss quite a few of them (salt water and metal don’t mix). But since these pickles don’t need to be sealed, you can use those neat looking old-fashioned metal bailed jars (Lehman’s Hardware carries the rings if you need new ones), whether they are of old or new make.

As a bonus, the fermented brine is wonderful in itself -- used in biscuits or breads, dressings or sauces, soups or sautes. It adds an extra something which is hard to describe but is missed when it is gone. But by far the hardest thing about these pickles is waiting long enough for some flavor to develop before eating them all up. And keeping some for gifts and for later eating. It’s a problem I can live with.

* * * * * *

Copyright Susan Robishaw
originally printed in the July/August 2009 issue of "Countryside Magazine"

Back to top

To comment
, ask questions, or just say Hi - click here  Contact Us. We enjoy hearing from our online friends and visitors!

Enjoy our articles? We appreciate DONATIONs of any amount! It helps to keep the website going. Click HERE to donate to ManyTracks using: Credit Cards logos.     Thank You!!

* Should you want to use all or part of one of our articles in a non-profit publication, website or blog we simply ask that you give proper credit and link (such as "article by Sue Robishaw/Steve Schmeck from"), and we'd enjoy knowing where it is used. Thanks!

       We always appreciate links to our site from appropriate sites, and we thank you for recommending us!

Have you read  "Frost Dancing - Tips from a Northern Gardener" ? A fun short read.

or "Homesteading Adventures"    Creating our backwoods homestead--the first 20 years.

and "Growing Berries for Food and Fun"   A journey you can use in your own garden.