MT Home



Other Fruit






The ManyTracks Orchard

Tart Cherries


A small fruit that doesn't need size or instant sweetness

to have a special place in the homestead orchard!


Evans Cherry fruit on tree

Bookmark and Share



Carmine Jewell





Cornelian Dogwood


My Cherry Path  (links to individual varieties pages in the menu above right)

   There was great success with our first tart cherry tree, an Evans on Mazzard rootstock, planted in probably the "warmest" location in the orchard, in full sun but near the woods protected by the large trees. It was a moderate sized tree, had very nice tart cherries, good crops when spring frosts and freezes were kind. It was hard to leave them to really mature to the best flavor, worrying if the birds would leave me enough (which they always did), but it was worth it when I did. I thoroughly enjoyed the five years when I had moderate to heavy crops (photo above), making wonderful fruit sauce. It didn't take me long to go searching for a cherry pitter after that first good crop, which was pitted by hand.

Two events did the healthy, sturdy Evans tree in -- raccoons and a heavy crop. Both resulted in badly broken branches two different years. Cherries don't handle such treatment well. Canker set in and at twelve years the tree was done. I was bummed as I'd gotten a taste of fresh home grown cherries and definitely wanted them back. It was five years before we once again had a crop of tart cherries, though small it was much appreciated. This was on a quite different cherry -- a University of Saskatchewan bred dwarf bush cherry, Carmine Jewell. We were back in the cherry swing, weather permitting. But this lady is very hardy, on her own roots, not depending on the Mazzard rootstock, and no ladder needed. The cherry breeding program at U of S is quite a story, from the passion of Dr. Les Kerr 60 years ago to the commitment of his later successor Rick Sawatzky, and Bob Bors. What they've accomplished is pretty amazing, and so appreciated by those who are growing the results of their work, myself included. Information on their dwarf bush cherries at

When we lost the first Evans I figured we'd just graft more cherries. We had been successfully grafting apples, pears, plums so it was a logical step. The Evans rootstock didn't throw up but one sucker maybe five feet away but we grafted onto that. I did have another cherry, a Meteor purchased several years after the Evans. It was small, in a different location, only growing to about 6 feet though on the same rootstock as Evans (which I kept pruned to 14 ft). I did get some fruit from it, nice, slightly smaller than Evans. But the raccoons also got into this tree and tore out branches, bark split, canker set in and we lost this one, too. This rootstock regrew vigorously, sending out many suckers which I dug up and replanted to graft. Intrigued by the difference between the two trees, both from Fedco, both supposedly on the same rootstock, I contacted them to see if the Meteor had by mistake been on a dwarfing or different rootstock. But no, Mazzard was the only rootstock they were using then. Interesting, but trees are individuals just as people are.

But I was happy to have the supply of rootstocks. I got more scions, more varieties. And I bought another tree, Garfield Plantation, also on Mazzard, the standard commercial hardy cherry rootstock. We grafted, some grew, some didn't, either the rootstocks or the scions winterkilled or damaged, or both. Garfield winterkilled also. Rootstocks regrew. We regrafted, same results. Obviously this wasn't working. I planted another University of Saskatchewan bush cherry, Juliet, and another Evans, this time on its own roots. We're in a frost pocket (bottom of a valley) in a moderately cold zone, z4 they say. I figure our homestead is in z3. I'm learning to respect that.

Juliet and Evans were planted in 2017, Carmine Jewell 2015. Carmine turned into a beautiful ornamental shrub, for awhile, giving a first small harvest in 2018; Evans started producing in 2022. When they are all in production this will be plenty of cherries for my use, but I wasn't ready to give up on grafting and trying other varieties. It's possible the rootstock is our weak link, not the varieties - see Meteor page for my next trial, and Mazzard page.


But it is "on their own roots" that I think is the way to go. I like that idea. Evans is available grown on its own roots from HoneyberryUSA (other sources usually graft it). This is where I got my new own root Evans (which is healthy and growing well). And the University of Saskatchewan bush cherries are naturally on their own roots. But other varieties are only to be had in the trade grafted onto other rootstocks. And it is very difficult to root plain cuttings.

So I dug up a Mazzard sucker, and we grafted Meteor onto it very low close to the roots. Then I replanted it deep, burying the graft and the bottom of the scion, leaving two buds above ground. It took and grew, small but healthy. The hope is that the buried part of the scion will put out its own roots thereby getting a Meteor tree growing on its own roots, using the Mazzard rootstock as a nurse root until it does. (I have several apples, apricots and a pear growing this way as well.) It's an exercise in patience but I hope it survives and grows. It will be interesting to see what this variety will do grown on its own roots. I may take a cutting from the newly grafted Mesabi and do the same with it.

Thus my cherry adventures continue.

Copyright Susan Robishaw

Back to top

To comment
, ask questions, or just say Hi - click here  Contact Us. We enjoy hearing from our online friends and visitors!

Enjoy our articles? We appreciate DONATIONs of any amount! It helps to keep the website going. Click HERE to donate to ManyTracks using: Credit Cards logos.     Thank You!!

* Should you want to use all or part of one of our articles in a non-profit publication, website or blog we simply ask that you give proper credit and link (such as "article by Sue Robishaw/Steve Schmeck from"), and we'd enjoy knowing where it is used. Thanks!

       We always appreciate links to our site from appropriate sites, and we thank you for recommending us!

Have you read  "Frost Dancing - Tips from a Northern Gardener" ? A fun short read.

or "Homesteading Adventures"    Creating our backwoods homestead--the first 20 years.

and "Growing Berries for Food and Fun"   A journey you can use in your own garden.